The Hartford Auto Insurance Review for 2024

The Hartford auto insurance company specializes in policies for senior drivers, but drivers under 50 might want to shop elsewhere.

The average monthly premium for a 50-year-old male is $124.75 with The Hartford, only $10 higher than the national average. The company offers all major car insurance coverage options with special incentives for seniors.

One unique program offered through AARP is RecoverCare. RecoverCare helps aid seniors after a car accident by helping with daily chores or household tasks for up to six months following an accident.

The company’s interactive website and mobile app help policyholders pay bills, get quotes, and file claims. The Hartford also offers home, business, and flood insurance through AARP.

You should get quotes from at least three different insurance companies before deciding on auto insurance. You never know which company is the right fit for you until you shop around.

What You Should Know About The Hartford

The Hartford ranks high among experts, including J.D. Power and the Better Business Bureau.

According to J.D. Power, The Hartford has above-average scores in every category, including claims servicing. The Hartford earned a score of 833 out of 1,000, which is above the industry average. In addition, J.D. Power gave the company four out of five stars in every category in its studies.

The Hartford also receives fewer customer complaints than other companies its size. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) scores companies by measuring the complaint index relative to the national median of 1.00. The Hartford scored 0.36 with NAIC, which is way below the national average.

A.M. Best also gave The Hartford an A+ (superior) rating on its financial strength, meaning the company has solid financial stability and is more than capable of paying out claims to its customers.

The negative complaints about the company focused on poor customer service, high rates, and delays in claim payments.

What are the pros and cons of The Hartford car insurance?

Like any company, The Hartford has positives and negatives. The Hartford has pretty good ratings overall, and customers seem satisfied overall.

The biggest pros for The Hartford insurance are:

• High customer satisfaction ratings with all of the experts
• Offers specialty insurance and benefits to seniors
• Agents are available 24/7 by phone and online

You’ll see in the section below that The Hartford has very good ratings from customers and several auto insurance coverages. The company also boasts an interactive website and mobile app to help policyholders get quotes, pay bills, and file claims.

In contrast, let’s look at the cons of The Hartford:

• Not the best choice for those under 50
• Rates are a little above average
• Customers complain of delays in claims payments

The Hartford designs its policies as auto insurance for older adults, so drivers in their mid-30s will probably find better coverage elsewhere. In addition, rates are often slightly above average, and some customers complain of claims taking a long time to pay out.

For the most part, The Hartford is a good insurance company and a great option for those 50 and older.

The Hartford Insurance Coverage Options

When shopping for auto insurance, it’s important to understand the difference between the most common types of auto insurance and what’s right for you. Through its partnership with AARP, Hartford offers all common car insurance options, from liability insurance to full coverage.

Most states require minimum liability insurance before drivers can get on the road. For added protection, you can add full coverage auto insurance that includes collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist coverage.

Check out the most common auto insurance coverage options below and what they mean:

• Bodily injury and property damage liability. Liability auto insurance pays for injuries, deaths, or property damage to others from an at-fault accident.
• Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. Pays for medical and property damage if you get hit by a driver without proper insurance.
• Collision insurance coverage. Pays for your repairs from traffic-related accidents, regardless of fault.
• Comprehensive insurance coverage. Pays for repairs from non-collision events, such as fire, falling debris, vandalism, animals, etc.

In addition, AARP adds other features to most of its policies, specifically for seniors. One of these features is the RecoverCare program.

What is the RecoverCare program?

RecoverCare helps aid seniors after a car accident by helping with daily chores or household tasks that are now difficult because of the accident. Depending on your location and policy, seniors can often use RecoverCare for up to six months or until they spend up to $2,500.

These daily tasks include transportation, food preparation, cleaning, lawn mowing, and dog walking. This program is incredibly popular because of the huge burden it takes off of seniors and their caretakers.

What other options are available through The Hartford?

There are other notable options offered by The Hartford, including:

• New car replacement. This protection will replace a new vehicle with less than 15,000 miles if you total it within the first 15 months.
• Accident forgiveness. Drivers won’t see an increase in their rates after an accident if they’ve gone five years with a clean driving record.
• Disappearing deductibles. Drivers with clean records may see their deductible decrease to $0 after years without an accident.
• Legal assistance. AARP also offers legal assistance to its customers.

As you can see, The Hartford doesn’t lack coverage options. Customers have all of the basic car insurance options and specialized programs fit for seniors. You’ll have no problem finding the coverage you need with The Hartford.

What other programs does The Hartford offer?

A unique program offered by The Hartford is the Advantage Program. This exclusive program offers additional benefits, including lifetime renewability, 12-month auto insurance rate protection, RecoverCare, lifetime car repair assurance, and more.

Lifetime renewability and 12-month rate protection make it easy for policyholders to renew with The Hartford. Unlike most insurance companies, the Hartford locks in rates for a full year instead of six months.

So customers can feel secure knowing their rates won’t increase if their driving and payment history remain in good standing. They also won’t be denied coverage with The Hartford.

Advantage Plus Program

In addition, The Hartford offers an Advantage Plus Program. This program offers everything listed above plus the following:

• Accident forgiveness
• Vanishing deductible
• One deductible
• Deductible waived

Through the Advantage Program and the Advantage Plus Program, team members are available to assist you day and night through a 24/7 claims hotline.

What online auto insurance tools does The Hartford have?

The Hartford has an outstanding online presence and offers several support tools through its website. The Hartford’s website has a rate calculator where drivers can provide information such as ZIP code, age, credit score, etc. to get a custom quote.

Customers can also pay their bills online and file claims. You can also track the status of a current claim on the website.

The Hartford’s mobile app is also very user-friendly. Policyholders can pay bills, view account details, request roadside assistance, and manage claims all through The Hartford’s mobile app.

How do I file a car insurance claim with The Hartford?

As mentioned above, drivers can file a claim through the company website and mobile app, making it easy to document an accident and initiate the claims process immediately.

For a more personal experience, you can always file a claim over the phone. Agents are available 24/7 to help.

However, the few customer complaints we found mentioned extra long wait times for claims processing.

What other insurance products does The Hartford sell?

Besides auto insurance, The Hartford offers several other insurance products. You can bundle your auto insurance with other policies for the biggest discounts.

Other insurance products offered by The Hartford include:

• Homeowners insurance. Pays for home damages, personal property damages, and temporary living expenses if your home is inhabitable.
• Renters insurance. Protects belongings in a rental from incidents such as fire, theft, and storms. This policy includes liability claims, living expenses, property damage, and medical payments.
• Umbrella insurance. Additional coverage options for specific situations and claims that exceed the limits of your existing insurance coverage.
• Condo insurance. Protects you from personal property loss, personal liability, and any other expenses related to your condominium. This coverage is customizable based on your needs and budget.
• Flood insurance. AARP stands out by offering flood insurance, while most insurers don’t.
• Business insurance. Protects you from business-related losses. It also covers lost wages for employees with work-related illnesses or injuries.

As you can see, AARP and The Hartford offer just about every type of insurance you could want.

The Hartford Insurance Rates Breakdown

The Hartford has competitive prices, and rates stay around the national average in most categories. The company’s average monthly rate is $124.75, around $1,497 annually. This data considers a 50-year-old male with a clean driving record and full coverage.

While you can get an average of how much you might pay for car insurance with The Hartford, several factors will impact your rate. Most insurance companies consider specific factors when determining a driver’s premium.

With The Hartford, you can expect the following factors to impact your overall rates:

• Age
• ZIP code
• Driving history
• Credit score
• Car make and model
• Desired coverage

You should get a direct quote from The Hartford if you’re curious about how much you would pay for car insurance with the company. Still, you can use averages to understand better how much a car insurance policy with The Hartford would cost.

Below, we detail how you can expect your rates to fluctuate depending on different circumstances.

How much is The Hartford by coverage?

Many drivers, especially people who owe money on their vehicles or have newer cars, choose a full coverage policy, including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage, to ensure their vehicle stays protected.

If you want full vehicle coverage, compare The Hartford quotes to ensure you don’t pay too much. The national average for full coverage is $114 per month. So rates with The Hartford aren’t much more expensive than most companies.

Look at the table below to get an idea of how much insurers charge on average for coverage.

Average Monthly Full Coverage Auto Insurance Rates by Company

The average cost for minimum liability car insurance coverage with The Hartford is $62 per month, compared to the national average of $54.

Geico and Progressive offer some of the most affordable rates in both categories, while Allstate and State Farm have the most expensive coverage.

There are many factors that insurance companies consider when setting rates. As mentioned above, age, driving history, and credit score shape car insurance rates.

How much is The Hartford by age?

This company caters to seniors specifically, so its rates for senior drivers will be competitive.

A 60-year-old female with The Hartford pays $119 per month on average. To compare, these women pay $139 per month with Allstate.

Check out the chart below to see the benefits offered to seniors by The Hartford.

Perks for Seniors with The Hartford Auto Insurance

Even though The Hartford specializes in senior auto insurance, it still offers insurance to teenagers. The average rate for teenagers with The Hartford is $304 per month, which is cheaper than the national average of $349 per month.

Average Monthly Full Coverage Teenage Auto Insurance Rates for the Top Insurance Companies

The table below shows what benefits are available to young student drivers.

Auto Insurance Discounts Available to Students from The Hartford

Drivers between the ages of 35 and 50 pay the lowest price for car insurance. Look at the table below to get an idea of what discounts The Hartford has for the average adult.

Common Auto Insurance Discounts Offered by The Hartford

Alongside age, past driving history is another significant factor in determining a driver’s car insurance premium.

How much is The Hartford by driving history?

Drivers with tickets on their record or multiple accidents are considered high-risk drivers. Insurance companies charge more for insurance with high-risk drivers since these people are more likely to file a claim.

Receiving just one speeding ticket can raise your rates with The Hartford to $190 per month or $2,283 per year. The national average is around $156 per month.

Look at the table below to see how much other top insurance companies raise rates after different types of traffic infractions.

Average Monthly Full Coverage Auto Insurance Rates by Driving Record

You may see an even larger rate increase if you’ve caused an accident while driving. If you’re at fault in an accident and don’t have accident forgiveness, your rates can increase by 20%.

It isn’t surprising that drivers see the largest rate increase if they receive a DUI charge since they’re especially high-risk. Some insurance companies won’t even provide car insurance to these drivers.

You can see how it pays to keep a clean driving record. Insurance companies like to see drivers with no negative marks on their driving records before offering them the best prices.

How much is The Hartford insurance by credit score?

Another determining factor for your car insurance premium is your credit score. Not all insurance companies consider your credit score, but many do. A good credit score shows the insurer that you have a history of paying your bills on time and are less likely to file a claim.

You can compare rates with the top insurance companies by credit score in the chart below.

Full Coverage Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Credit Score

Across most driver profiles, The Hartford is typically cheaper than Allstate and State Farm auto insurance. On the other hand, The Hartford has more expensive rates than Progressive and Geico auto insurance.

We always recommend that you get quotes from at least three different insurance companies when shopping for auto insurance. Every driver is unique, and you never know what you’ll pay with each company until you get a quote.

The Hartford Discounts Available

AARP offers a wide range of auto insurance discounts through The Hartford. Customers won’t have a problem finding one or multiple discounts for lower rates.

Below is a list of discounts The Hartford offers:

• Bundling insurance policies
• Driving a hybrid vehicle
• Air bag and anti-lock brakes discount
• Anti-theft discount
• Multi-vehicle policy
• New vehicle discount
• Home ownership
• Paid-in-full
• Student away-from-home discount

Some of these discounts can save you up to 20% on your auto insurance.

For example, The Hartford offers a 5%-15% discount if you have certain anti-theft devices on your vehicle. You can save 10%-20% if you install the proper air bag.

Another discount AARP offers is its defensive driving program, the AARP Smart Driver Course. Drivers have 60 days to complete the online course, which allows them to apply for discounts for the next 36 months.

Not all discounts will be available in your area, so speak with a company representative to find out which may apply to you. Not all discounts will be available in your area, so make sure you speak with an insurance agent to find out which may apply to you.